NYC equivalent of London’s Fortnum and Mason?

NYC Afternoon Tea

Lady Mendl’s: I had high hopes for Lady Mendl’s because of it’s great reviews. The tea salon is situated in a brownstone building just off of Union Square with beautiful décor. I had the “Lady Mendl’s” tea which was delicious. But towards the end of the pot, the tea got cold very quickly. The food was good but nothing to rave about. The sandwiches were average. The scones were warm and scrumptious with clotted cream. I wasn’t a fan of the signature cake, and the cookies tasted store bought. I did however enjoy the chocolate covered strawberry. I wouldn’t go back for the food, but I would for the tea and the overall atmosphere. The service was friendly and attentive and I never felt rushed. So overall, I had a nice, enjoyable afternoon tea in a beautiful atmosphere.

Lady Mendl's
Lady Mendl’s
56 Irving Pl
New York, NY 10003
$40, plus tax and gratuity

The Palm Court: When you think of afternoon tea in NYC, the luxury hotels seem like the quintessential place, but The Palm Court inside the famed Plaza Hotel was a complete let down. Overall, the place felt very touristy, and the service reflected that. When we sat down, my friend did not have a plate, and even after the food was brought out, it was difficult to find our waiter to bring her a plate. There was no apology either for the inconvenience. The sandwiches were barely edible. They didn’t taste fresh. The scones were warm and good. I did not like the desserts, and only had a small taste of each. I did enjoy the tea. I won’t be returning here, not for the food or the atmosphere.
The Palm Court
The Palm Court at the Plaza Hotel
Fifth Avenue at Central Park South
New York, NY 10019
 $50-$60, plus tax and gratuity


London: Fortnum and Mason

Afternoon tea at Fortnum and Mason.
Experiencing afternoon tea is an absolute must when visiting London. Fortnum and Mason came with high recommendations, and it exceeded them all! From the delicious sandwiches to the warm crumbly scones, and finally the savory desserts. Everything was absolutely delicious, including the rich, hot tea.
The service is impeccable, everyone is polite and professional, which made the overall experience that much more enjoyable. Afterwards, don’t forgot to check out the other floors (there are 5 in total) selling everything from tea and desserts to kitchenware.


Fortnum and Mason Fortnum and Mason

Fortnum and Mason